The Working Life Edit
The Room You Earned Your Place In (Even When You Don’t Feel Like It)
Imposter syndrome at work, promotions, university degrees and what honest feedback has taught me about finding my feet in leadership.
8 min read

A work-from-home desk, with coffee.
There is something slightly absurd about getting a promotion and immediately wondering when somebody is going to discover you cannot do the job.
You have worked for the opportunity. Somebody has trusted you with the responsibility. There is presumably a perfectly good reason you were asked to take the next step.
And yet there you are, sitting in a meeting, surrounded by people who look as though they were born knowing exactly what they are doing, thinking: Well, this is lovely. How long before they find me out?
I know that feeling. I have had it more than once.
I am 42, I have built a career in management and I have accumulated a great deal of practical experience along the way. That does not mean I have always felt wonderfully confident at the beginning of every new role. Quite the opposite, sometimes.
What makes it interesting is that the feeling rarely lasts.
The strange first weeks after a promotion
I have noticed a pattern in my own career. When I step into a new job, especially one with more responsibility, I can go through a period of questioning myself.
Do I know enough? Will I meet the expectations? Did the people who appointed me perhaps see something I cannot yet see myself?
And, of course, the question that is probably the least useful of the lot: when am I going to be found out?
A few weeks later, I usually find myself comfortably doing the very job I was so worried about. I understand the people, the decisions, the priorities and the particular way things work. I start to recognise what I can contribute. The role becomes familiar.
Nothing magical happened overnight. I learnt my way into it.
I think that distinction matters: being new to something is not the same as being incapable of doing it.
It sounds obvious when you read it in a calm moment. It feels rather less obvious in the middle of a new management meeting.
When everyone seems to have six master’s degrees
Another part of this is the environment in which you work.
I work with highly educated people, and sometimes it feels as though everybody around me went to university and has six master’s degrees to show for it.
I didn’t go to university when I was younger.
My career developed step by step. I took opportunities, learnt through doing, developed my judgement and built experience in management. I am proud of that route. It has given me skills I use every day.
But I would be pretending if I said an impressive room full of academic qualifications never made me feel a little small.
There is a strange temptation to compare somebody else’s list of degrees with the version of your own career that you can fit into one sentence. You forget the years of decisions and difficult conversations, the teams you have led, the things you have learnt because you were actually responsible for making them work.
A university education is valuable. So is experience. This isn’t a competition between the two.
And at 42, I am now following a leadership programme at Nyenrode Business Universiteit myself.
I am genuinely proud of that.
Not because I need a university’s approval to make the career I have built legitimate, but because I want to keep developing. I enjoy learning. I am curious about what is next. And I certainly don’t believe professional growth has to be completed by the time you turn 30.
Life would become rather dull if that were the rule.
Is this an especially familiar feeling for women?
I often wonder whether expectations play a role in this, too.
My impression is that society can still look at women in senior management differently, or expect something different of us. Perhaps that adds another layer of pressure when we take on more responsibility.
I wouldn’t claim that every woman feels this way, and men certainly experience professional self-doubt as well. I can only speak from my own perspective.
But I do think the subject deserves more honest conversation, especially among women whose careers look very successful from the outside.
It is easy to assume that a capable, energetic person who knows how to lead a meeting must always feel certain of herself.
Sometimes she does. Sometimes she is quietly wondering whether she knows nearly enough.
And sometimes the culture of a workplace, meaning which achievements are celebrated, whose expertise is noticed and what a leader is expected to look like, may be part of the story.
Not every uncomfortable feeling belongs entirely to the individual.
Why I ask for feedback twice a year
Here is what has helped me more than telling myself to just be confident.
At the beginning and the end of the year, I ask my direct colleagues for feedback.
I don’t do it because I want a little round of applause. Of course, it is lovely to hear when somebody thinks you are doing a good job. But I want structured feedback that gives me something to work with.
What am I doing well? What do people value in the way I work? What could be better? Is there something I haven’t noticed?
You have to be prepared for the possibility that the answer will not be especially comfortable. If you ask for honest feedback, people might tell you something you would rather not hear. That is part of the deal.
When somebody identifies something useful to improve, I can do something with it. I can adjust, learn and become better at what I do. And when somebody describes a strength, it helps me understand how my work is experienced by the people around me.
Both kinds of feedback matter.
The feedback I hadn’t expected to mean so much
One of the comments from my most recent feedback round stayed with me.
Colleagues told me they appreciated the way I approach innovation and the energy I bring to our management team.
That was genuinely lovely to hear.
Not because it meant somebody had declared me perfect, but because it named something specific I contribute. Something that isn’t expressed through the number of degrees on a CV.
It helped me see myself a little more clearly through somebody else’s eyes.
That is one of the reasons I like feedback when it is done properly. It can strengthen your confidence and still give you new things to work on. Those are not opposites.
The questions I find more useful than “Am I doing OK?”
If you are stepping into a new role, I would encourage a more useful conversation than simply asking for reassurance.
Try asking a trusted colleague:
- What do you think I have contributed well so far? Ask for an example rather than a polite generality.
- Where could I improve my approach? You are looking for something actionable, not a character judgement.
- What should I keep doing? Strengths deserve attention, too.
- Is there anything you think I am not seeing yet? Sometimes a different perspective is exactly what you need.
Then listen. Ask a follow-up question when something is unclear. Decide what is useful. Take action where action is needed.
Not every opinion is automatically correct, and you do not have to remodel yourself around every piece of feedback. The point is to gather information rather than let an anxious thought become the only voice in the room.
What I remind myself at the beginning of something new
I wish I could say that years of experience have made the feeling disappear permanently.
They haven’t.
But I have learnt to recognise the pattern.
I know the first weeks can feel uncertain. I know that learning the ropes takes time. I know I can ask questions without being incompetent. I know that experience has value, even when I am sitting beside somebody with an impressive academic background.
I also know that there will always be something I can improve.
I don’t need to choose between being proud of my experience and being open to learning. I can do both. I am doing both, including by studying again at 42.
Perhaps this is what a more grown-up version of confidence looks like: not insisting that you have every answer, but being willing to find out, listen, adapt and trust that you have something worthwhile to contribute.
You belong in the room while you are still learning
If you have just taken a step up and you are worried that the room is full of people who know far more than you, I understand.
Maybe they do know more about particular things. That is why working with talented people can be so interesting.
But they don’t have your precise experience, either.
Give yourself the time to learn the new role. Invite feedback that is specific enough to use. Notice the strengths that other people recognise in you. Keep developing, whether you are 27, 42 or 62.
And when that little voice asks when somebody is going to find you out, perhaps ask it a better question:
What if I am simply learning to feel at home in a place I have already earned?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is imposter syndrome at work?
It is a common description for the experience of doubting your achievements or fearing that others will discover you are less capable than they think. The term describes a feeling; it is not a formal medical diagnosis.
Can experienced managers experience imposter feelings?
Yes. A new role, a promotion or unfamiliar expectations can bring uncertainty even when someone has substantial professional experience. Feeling new is not in itself evidence of being unqualified.
What helps when I feel out of my depth in a new role?
Allow time to learn, distinguish actual development needs from assumptions, and seek specific feedback from people whose professional judgement you trust. Useful feedback can include both strengths and areas to improve.
Is it too late to keep studying in your forties?
No. I have started a leadership programme at Nyenrode at 42. For me, learning is part of an ongoing career, not something with a deadline at 30.
A small reflection
If this feels familiar, think about the last time you entered a new professional situation. What did you assume you lacked? What did you learn? And if you asked the people who work with you what you contribute, what might they say?
You don’t need to make the answers into another self-improvement project. Sometimes noticing them is enough.
If you are curious about the place I do much of my thinking, here is my living room home office. And for the other side of a full diary, I wrote about the Grown-Up Hobby Club, my cousin’s and my tradition of trying something we are not required to be good at.
Explore more practical everyday systems in The Working Life Edit.
Written by Esther, founder of Essy’s Essentials, from her own working life. This is a personal account, not psychological or professional advice.

Written by Esther
Esther is a photographer and storyteller, and the founder of Essy's Essentials - a seasonal home for stories, rituals, recipes and everyday luxuries.
More about Esther →